• Informative rating
    32 replies, posted
  • Avatar of Karl L
  • The informative rating should be brought back. It would especially go well with the question/answer threads in the future.
  • Avatar of postal
  • Yea this is a good one. I mean if a post is SUPER informative you could give it a coin, but I'd think informative could still have some usage.
  • Avatar of Teddybeer
  • Everyone and their dog making emoticon sets really is the worst thing that has happened in recent years.
  • Avatar of Emperor Sagan
  • I agree, and also I still enjoy rating the weirdest or outlandish posts 'informative' as it has always been.
  • Avatar of Liam
  • that was my favourite bit of Deviantart Appreciation Station
  • Avatar of havasu
  • would be nice yeah, regardless I'd personally give a coin the Good Idea rating will suffice for now
  • Avatar of SquidsEye
  • Coins kind of double as a bumped up version of any positive rating, I'd say it's closer to winner than informative though.
  • Avatar of Clive
  • I did actually use this rating a lot, that and friendly but friendly is already here so that's good.
  • Avatar of SquidsEye
  • I like the curly one but I think the i needs shifting over to the left a little.
  • Avatar of Reagy
  • My only gripe is that your designs don't follow the MS design standard which all the rest are. Recommend giving it a look.
  • Avatar of Pyth
  • https://i.imgur.com/GbDRXR0.png https://i.imgur.com/UoBpGMF.png
  • Avatar of Emperor Sagan
  • I think this are pretty good. I prefer the straight one thats more similar to the original informative rating, though maybe since we're on newpunch a fresh new informative rating would be best?
  • Avatar of AtomicSans
  • Somehow I don't think Garry wouldn't use any icons that aren't pulled straight from the Microsoft emoji set.
  • Avatar of northshore
  • I'm just wondering why the Microsoft emoji set in the first place. You'd think the Apple emojis would be the most recognizable/mainstream. unless that was the point
  • Avatar of AtomicSans
  • Maybe because the Apple emojis look fucking horrible and aren't even consistent with themselves? Say what you want about the Microsoft emojis but they're distinctive and super consistent in style.
  • Avatar of NeatNit
  • Just take this one exactly as it is but change it to a circle for a guaranteed Microsoft look?
  • Avatar of Rimbas
  • Still think just recreating existing silk icon with MS guidelines is fine. Not visible in 24px but if 72px is used anywhere, I think top one with curves looks better
  • Avatar of Kecske
  • Slightly tweaked yours, I think the more vivid blue fits in with the rest of the icons better. Also the rings look a bit better at 24px now imo.
  • Avatar of damnatus
  • Not to say it contrasts with the rest of newpunch emojis, which are mostly round